RTWO Architecture Validation Report
RTWO Architecture v1.0 — Phases 1–20
Fix Progress
18 of 43 addressedOverall Architecture Readiness Score
49%Architecture structure is well-defined (Phases 1–20 complete). Production readiness is blocked by zero inter-engine connectivity, no persistence layer, and no startup orchestration.
Critical Findings — Status
Partial fix applied: All mock data access in orchestrator.ts is now gated behind isMockDataAllowed() which checks RTWO_REQUIRE_REAL_DATA and RTWO_ALLOW_DEMO_DATA env vars. When RTWO_REQUIRE_REAL_DATA=true (current production setting), all service methods return null/empty truthful states. The structural separation of mock-data.ts into separate files is deferred — it requires refactoring all 20+ mock data exports and is a non-trivial change that could break existing dashboard pages that import from mock-data.ts. Priority: Medium — the env var gate resolves the production safety concern.
Partial fix: Mock data is now gated behind RTWO_REQUIRE_REAL_DATA env var (see CD-001 fix). When RTWO_REQUIRE_REAL_DATA=true, all R1–R7 service methods return null/empty truthful states. Full delegation to specialized engine modules requires runtime dependency injection and a startup orchestrator (PR-002) — deferred as it requires architectural wiring beyond the scope of quality fixes. The env var gate ensures production safety.
Unresolved — Priority: Critical. Consolidating two event bus implementations requires a runtime startup orchestrator and wiring all 20 modules to RTWO-EBUS-001. This is a runtime connectivity concern that cannot be resolved by interface definitions alone. Prerequisite for: CD-003, CD-004, CD-005, IG-009. The IEventPublisher interface (MI-003 fix) defines the correct contract for when this is implemented. No new modules may be created per architecture constraints.
Unresolved — Priority: Critical. Consolidating the two event bus implementations requires migrating all CoreEventTypes to RTWO-EBUS-001 and updating all 20+ modules that use coreEventBus. This is a broad runtime change that cannot be done safely without a startup orchestrator and integration tests. Deprecating core-engine/event-bus.ts would break the Core Engine orchestrator. Deferred to a dedicated event bus consolidation phase.
isMockDataAllowed() guard added to src/lib/core-engine/orchestrator.ts. All R1–R7 service methods now check RTWO_REQUIRE_REAL_DATA and RTWO_ALLOW_DEMO_DATA before returning mock data. When RTWO_REQUIRE_REAL_DATA=true (current .env setting), all methods return null/empty truthful states. Mock data is only returned when RTWO_REQUIRE_REAL_DATA is not true AND RTWO_ALLOW_DEMO_DATA=true.
Unresolved — Priority: Critical. Implementing a startup orchestrator requires creating a new coordination module or extending the Integration Framework. Per architecture constraints, no new modules may be created. This is a production infrastructure concern that must be addressed before mainnet deployment. Prerequisite for: CD-002, CD-003, IG-002, IG-003, IG-005, IG-006, IG-007.
Unresolved — Priority: Critical. Circuit breaker implementation requires runtime wiring between all engine modules and the Integration Framework's policy enforcement layer. This is a production infrastructure concern requiring a startup orchestrator (PR-002) as a prerequisite.